How to choose a GEO agency: 12 questions to ask and 7 red flags
What is a GEO agency, and how is it different from an SEO agency?
An SEO agency works to rank your pages in a list of links. A GEO agency works to get your business named inside the AI answer, and measures whether that happens. The two overlap a lot: AI features in Google Search use the same core systems as normal search, and other AI tools often search the web before they answer. So good GEO always includes SEO basics.
| Traditional SEO agency | GEO agency | |
|---|---|---|
| Main goal | Higher Google rankings and clicks | Being named, cited and described correctly in AI answers |
| What it measures | Keyword positions, organic traffic | Mention rate and share of voice across a fixed set of buyer questions, plus traffic and leads from AI tools |
| Content style | Long articles built around keywords | Answer-first pages with clear facts, prices, comparisons and sources that AI can quote |
| Work off your site | Backlinks | Mentions on directories, review sites, media, forums and comparison lists that AI uses as sources |
| Tools covered | Google (sometimes Bing) | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and Google AI features |
Should you upgrade your SEO agency or hire a specialist GEO agency?
If your current SEO agency already tests AI answers and reports on them, keep it. If it cannot show you what ChatGPT says about you today, you need someone who can. Many SEO agencies are adding GEO, and some do it well. The test is not the label on the proposal but whether the agency can show its question list, its testing method and dated results.
What 12 questions should you ask a GEO agency before you sign?
- Which buyer questions will you test, and can I see the list? You should be able to add or remove questions.
- Which AI tools do you test, and how? Look for fresh sessions, a fixed location and language, and saved answers with their sources.
- What is my baseline today? A good agency shows your starting mention rate before you pay for monthly work.
- Which competitors are named instead of us, and which websites does AI cite? This tells you where the work needs to happen.
- What will you change on my website in the first 30 days? Expect specifics: pages, Schema, crawler access, facts and prices.
- Where will you build mentions off my site, and how? Ask for the types of sites and the method, and ask whether any placement is paid.
- What do you report every month? Mention rate, share of voice, citations, AI referral traffic and leads, not only article counts.
- Can I see dated before-and-after results for a real client? Ask how the numbers were measured and whether the client agreed to share them.
- What is the price, what is included, and what is the minimum term? Get it in writing.
- Who writes the content, and who checks the facts? AI-written pages with wrong facts can hurt you.
- Do I own the content, accounts and listings if we stop? You should.
- What happens if results do not move after three months? A good agency explains why and changes the plan.
What are the red flags of standard SEO sold as GEO?
- A guarantee of mentions in ChatGPT or Perplexity. Nobody controls what AI tools say. Honest agencies promise work and measurement, not outcomes.
- No baseline and no question list. If there is nothing to compare against, there is no way to show progress.
- Reports that only show keyword rankings and backlinks. These matter, but they are SEO reports, not GEO reports.
- Screenshots without dates, prompts or sources. One lucky answer proves little. AI answers vary between sessions.
- Bulk AI-written articles or hundreds of thin pages. AI tools favour clear, accurate, well-sourced pages, and Google treats scaled low-value content as spam.
- Fake reviews, paid Reddit comments posing as customers, or hidden text for AI. These are grey or black-hat tactics that can damage your reputation and break platform rules.
- Vague pricing that changes once you ask for details. Fixed scopes are easier to judge.
Can a GEO agency guarantee mentions inside ChatGPT or Perplexity?
No. AI answers change with the question wording, the user’s location, the model version and what the tool finds on the web that day. What an agency can do is improve the signals AI tools rely on, such as clear pages, consistent facts and trusted mentions, and then measure your mention rate across many questions over time. A rising mention rate across 20 or 40 questions is a much better sign than one screenshot.
How should larger companies choose a GEO agency?
Run a small paid test before a long contract. Pick one product line or market, agree on 20 to 40 buyer questions, record the baseline across four or five AI tools, and give the agency three months. Check that the agency can work with your legal and brand teams, report by market and language, and share raw answer logs, not only summary charts. For B2B brands, ask specifically how the agency builds mentions in industry media, analyst-style comparison pages and review platforms, because those are common sources for B2B answers.
How CitedAsia answers these questions
We show your baseline in a free snapshot, test 20 questions across four AI tools in the audit, publish fixed prices on our pricing page and publish dated results on our case studies page. We do not guarantee AI mentions. See how we work as a GEO agency in Singapore, or compare us with others in GEO agencies in Singapore compared.
Frequently asked questions
What is a GEO agency?
A GEO (generative engine optimization) agency helps a business get named, cited and described correctly in answers from AI tools such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI. It tests buyer questions, fixes the website so AI can read it, builds trusted mentions on other sites and re-tests the results.
Is a GEO agency just an SEO agency with a new name?
Sometimes. A real GEO service tests AI answers with a fixed question list, reports mention rate and share of voice, and works on the sources AI cites. If you only get keyword rankings and backlink counts, it is an SEO service.
Can a GEO agency guarantee that ChatGPT will recommend my business?
No. Nobody controls what AI tools say. An agency can improve the signals AI relies on and measure results honestly, but it should never promise a recommendation.
How do I know a GEO agency is not using black-hat tactics?
Ask how every mention is created. Fake reviews, paid comments posing as customers, hidden text and bulk AI-written pages are red flags. Legitimate work includes clear website content, accurate listings, real reviews, media coverage and genuine expert answers.
How many questions should a GEO agency test?
For a small business, 20 questions across four AI tools is a practical start. Larger brands often track 40 to 100 questions split by product, market and language.
Want to see your baseline first? Our free AI visibility snapshot tests five of your customers’ questions in ChatGPT and Perplexity and sends a report within 24 hours.
Updated November 2026 · Written by Dawn, Founder of CitedAsia · Sources: Google Search Central, AI features and your website; Google Search spam policies; Aggarwal et al., GEO: Generative Engine Optimization (KDD 2024) · Rankings up, no enquiries · Implementation vs recommendations · SEO & GEO agency in Singapore
Is your business in the answer?
Free check of 5 customer questions on ChatGPT and Perplexity. Score in 30 seconds, full report within 24 hours (business days).