My SEO agency reports higher rankings but I get no enquiries. What should I look for in a replacement?
Why can rankings go up while enquiries stay flat?
Usually because the rankings are for the wrong searches, the pages do not convert, or nobody is tracking enquiries. These are the most common causes we see:
- Rankings for searches with no buying intent. Ranking first for “what is corporate secretarial service” brings readers. Ranking for “corporate secretary service Singapore price” brings buyers. Many reports count both the same.
- Average position hides the detail. An average can improve because hundreds of long, rarely searched phrases moved up, while the five searches that bring customers did not move at all.
- The page ranks but does not persuade. No prices or price range, no proof such as reviews or client results, no clear next step, a slow mobile page, or a contact form buried at the bottom.
- Enquiries are not measured. If form submissions, WhatsApp clicks and phone calls are not tracked, nobody can tell which pages produce customers, so the agency reports what it can measure: rankings and traffic.
- Buyers now get their shortlist from AI. More people ask ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google AI “which company is reliable?” and only contact the few names in the answer. A page can rank well in the list of links and still never be named in the AI answer.
- The local listing is ignored. For local services, many calls come from the Google Business Profile, not the website. If it has few reviews or wrong details, rankings on the website do not fix that.
What should you check before you switch agencies?
Spend an hour on five checks. They show whether the problem is the agency, the website or the tracking.
| Check | Where to look | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Which searches bring clicks | Google Search Console, Queries report | Whether the top queries are buyer searches (service + location, price, “best”, “near me”) or general questions |
| Which pages get the visits | Search Console, Pages report | Whether visits land on service pages or only on blog posts |
| Whether enquiries are tracked | Google Analytics 4, Key events | Whether form submissions, WhatsApp and phone clicks are counted at all |
| Calls from your listing | Google Business Profile, Performance | How many calls, website clicks and direction requests come from Google Maps |
| Who AI recommends | Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI the questions your buyers ask | Whether your business is named, and which competitors are named instead |
For the last check, our 15-minute self-test walks you through it.
What should a replacement SEO agency do differently?
Look for an agency that treats enquiries as the result and rankings as one of the ways to get there. In practice that means it will:
- Measure your enquiries before it starts. A baseline of forms, WhatsApp messages and calls per month, set up in your own Google Analytics account.
- Choose target searches by buying intent. Fewer keywords, picked because buyers use them, not because they are easy to rank for.
- Fix the money pages first. Service pages with the answer first, prices or price ranges, proof, FAQs and a clear way to contact you.
- Cover AI search as well as Google. Test the questions buyers ask in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI, and work on the reasons you are or are not named. This is often called GEO (generative engine optimisation). Read GEO vs SEO for the difference.
- Do the work, not only recommend it. Make the page, Schema and listing changes itself, or work directly with your developer, so the plan does not sit in a PDF.
- Report enquiries next to rankings. Every monthly report should show enquiries by source, which pages produced them, and what was changed that month.
What questions should you ask a new SEO agency?
- How will you measure enquiries, and will the tracking sit in my own Google Analytics account?
- Which 10 searches will you target first, and why do buyers use them?
- Which of my pages will you change in the first month, and who makes the changes?
- Will you test whether ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI recommend me, and show me the results?
- What will the monthly report show besides rankings and traffic?
- Can I see a report you sent another client, with the name hidden?
- Is the price fixed and written down, and how long is the minimum contract?
- If I leave, do I keep all accounts, content and tracking?
What are the red flags in a replacement agency?
- Reports that show rankings and traffic but no enquiries, and no plan to measure them.
- Guaranteed first-page rankings, or guaranteed mentions in ChatGPT. Nobody controls either.
- Large keyword lists chosen for volume, with no explanation of buyer intent.
- Only recommendations, with no one responsible for making changes on your website.
- Google Analytics, Search Console or your Business Profile owned by the agency instead of you.
- A 12-month lock-in before you have seen any result.
How do you switch agencies without losing what already works?
- Get ownership first. Make sure you are the owner, not just a user, of Google Search Console, Google Analytics, Google Business Profile and your domain.
- Export the history. Keep past reports and a list of the content and links the old agency created.
- Do not delete pages that rank. Improve them. If a page must move, set up a 301 redirect.
- Agree on a baseline with the new agency on enquiries, buyer searches and AI mentions, dated, so you can judge them fairly after three months.
How does CitedAsia handle this?
We combine SEO and GEO, make the changes on your website ourselves, and judge the work by enquiries as well as visibility. Our AI visibility audit costs USD 690 and tests 20 buyer questions across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI, checks your site, compares you with the competitors AI names, and gives you a written 30-day plan. Monthly plans start at USD 1,200 with a 3-month minimum, and include the page and Schema fixes.
To be clear about where we are: CitedAsia launched in October 2026. Our first case study shows AI visibility and Google search results, not enquiry numbers yet. We will publish enquiry results as clients agree to share them.
Frequently asked questions
Why do my rankings go up but enquiries do not?
Usually the rankings are for searches without buying intent, the pages that rank do not make it easy to contact you, or enquiries are not tracked. It can also be that buyers now get their shortlist from AI answers, where your business is not named.
Should I fire my SEO agency if rankings improve but leads do not?
First check which searches and pages bring the visits, and whether enquiries are tracked. If your agency cannot show buyer searches, page changes and enquiry tracking after you ask, it is reasonable to look for a replacement.
What should an SEO report include besides rankings?
Enquiries by source (forms, WhatsApp, calls), the pages that produced them, the buyer searches you rank for, Google Business Profile actions, whether AI tools name you, and the work done that month.
How long before a new SEO agency brings more enquiries?
Fixes to service pages and tracking can show within weeks. Ranking and AI visibility changes usually take 3 to 6 months. Agree on a dated baseline at the start so you can judge progress.
Updated November 2026 · Written by Dawn, Founder of CitedAsia · SEO & GEO agency in Singapore · How to choose a GEO agency · Measuring GEO ROI · Free AI visibility check · Ranking on Google but not in AI answers
Is your business in the answer?
Free check of 5 customer questions on ChatGPT and Perplexity. Score in 30 seconds, full report within 24 hours (business days).